# Why I think it's all starting to crumble at Cheshire Police: HITCHENS **By:** Peter Hitchens **Published:** 2026-08-23T01:00:59+0100 **Source:** [Daily Mail](https://www.dailymail.com/columnists/article-16072023/lucy-letby-cheshire-police-peter-hitchens.html) --- PETER HITCHENS: Cheshire police once boasted how it caught Lucy Letby - but now its chief has quit, with no mention of the controversial case. This is why I think it's all starting to crumble at the force... What is going on in Cheshire’s police force. This bold body once made a boastful film about how they caught Lucy Letby. Now they have rather suddenly got rid of their Chief Constable, two years early. Almost at the top of his recent retirement statement, Chief Constable Mark Roberts made it clear he wasn’t going because he wanted to, or when he wanted to. He said: ‘I had hoped to take the force through to 2028, but the decision has been made to take the force in a different direction.’ Why? We are not told. I have used up millions of electrons trying to find out. Cheshire police would say only: ‘The Chief’s contract is a matter for the Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC)’. I have sought a response from the office of the Cheshire PCC, but have received none. The Home Office in London say it is nothing to do with them. What would Sherlock Holmes, the great detective, do? I think he would look at the timing, and also at the things which remain unsaid, or that people have stopped saying. Do you remember when Ms Letby was still supposed to be a monster of cruelty, the undoubted murderer of many babies? Cheshire’s finest were so proud of feeling her collar. A senior investigating officer, Paul Hughes, said the police investigation ran for six years and was ‘like no other in scope, complexity and magnitude’. He said: ‘It was a detailed and painstaking process by a team of almost 70 police officers, and no stone was left unturned.’ Well, we shall see about that. They even called their performance ‘Operation Hummingbird’, as if it was an invasion of somewhere. I am told they handed out hummingbird badges, desk ornaments and trinkets to each other to celebrate their supposed triumph. This went on for years. Mark Roberts, the former Chief Constable of the Cheshire Constabulary who has suddenly left his position Cheshire Police still believe they are right over the Lucy Letby case, writes Peter Hitchens But now their boss has revealed that he has been forced out, well before he wanted to go. Despite the fact that police forces are publicly financed bodies responsible to the voters, nobody has said why. Mr Roberts turns 59 on Tuesday and has held his post since 2021. If all is well with the Letby case, surely he should be able to have a couple of golden years before retiring? It seems not. His farewell statement, quite naturally, dwells on the many achievements of his force during his time in charge. But, oddly, he does not mention the investigation of Ms Letby – the most famous thing they have ever done. Why is that? His force still officially believes the case was one of its successes and that she deserves to die in jail. As recently as last January they exploded in noisy public displeasure when the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) refused to begin new prosecutions of the imprisoned nurse. The CPS said, devastatingly: ‘We concluded that the evidential test was not met in any of those cases.’ The proper thing for the police might have been to maintain a dignified silence after this smack in the face from some of the country’s most skilled and senior prosecution lawyers. But they still insisted they were right. They said sulkily: ‘This is not the outcome that we had anticipated throughout our investigation; we were confident that we held enough evidence to take to the CPS… We believed the evidence submitted met the CPS charging standard. The CPS did not agree.’ Absurdly, they asserted that the CPS announcement did ‘not affect or undermine the convictions of Lucy Letby’. But of course it does. The original prosecution should have been referred to the top of the CPS, to a national body called the Special Crime Division (SCD). There is no doubt that this is the rule in cases of alleged multiple murder, especially in hospitals. But for some reason that did not happen. What if it had? Would this lame, evidence-free prosecution ever have got to court in the first place? Interestingly, the argument about those new charges went on right up to Wednesday, August 5 this year. Some of the parents of the babies who had allegedly been harmed in these cases appealed to the CPS. They sought a ‘Victims’ Right of Review’. They asked, as was their right, for the CPS to reconsider its rejection of the new cases. But three weeks ago, the CPS announced the result of what it called ‘an extensive review of the case by a prosecutor independent of the original decisions, involving a re-examination of substantial evidence and material’ The review ‘upheld the original decision not to bring any further criminal charges’ against Lucy Letby. The CPS told media: ‘This represents a final decision by the CPS.’ And five days later, on Monday, August 10, Chief Constable Roberts announced his early departure. Is it all starting to crumble? I cannot say for sure because the people involved will not talk to me. But I think these events are hugely significant. The Soviet Army invades Czechoslovakia in 1968 following the Prague Spring demonstrations Why do Reds get away with repression? What a strange time of year this is – the very Dead of Summer, when nothing is supposed to happen. Yet major events often take place, and one burned on my memory is the Soviet invasion of Prague in 1968. The Kremlin had previously crushed protest in Berlin in 1953 and Budapest in 1956. The West did nothing. And in 1968 we did nothing again. Isn’t that interesting? It’s what we had agreed in 1945 at Yalta, when we handed over eastern Europe to Stalin. In my view, if Moscow’s Communists had behaved like the Chinese and violently crushed democratic protest in 1989, they would still be in charge of Europe and half of Berlin, and Western politicians would be travelling to the Kremlin to suck up to the Politburo. Why, they might even make us call Moscow ‘Moskva’, as the Chinese Communist Party has browbeaten us into calling Peking ‘Beijing’. The contrast between then and now is really very odd. Montana Brown criticises 'sick and twisted' companies for creating 'addictive' kids' TV shows and says she only lets her children watch screens 'on very rare occasions' Gemma Owen's chaotic TV hosting debut sees her get the names of the guests wrong before asking if she needs an international dialling code to call Wales Lionel Richie, 77, taken into intensive care in St Louis after falling ill on stage Coronation Street star Brooke Vincent 'splits from footballer fiancé Kean Bryan' after 10 years together Ollie Watkins and wife Ellie start their new life in Saudi Arabia with their children after WAG broke down in tears over footballer's sudden move from Aston Villa to Al-Hilal Zendaya celebrates her best year yet as she's named highest grossing actress, ties the knot with Tom Holland and is gearing up for another blockbuster release - all before turning 30 Nicole Kidman, 59, praised for her 'more natural' look with 'less Botox' as she appears in interview with Sandra Bullock: 'So much better' Oti Mabuse reveals she thinks AJ Pritchard is 'scared' as she takes another dig at the Strictly dancer as she weighs in on him competing in Dancing With The Stars in the US Green-fingered David Beckham impresses wife Victoria with his bizarrely shaped long pumpkin and plums as couple share innuendo-filled garden update Rod Stewart, 81, tucks into a burger and chips as he watches his local football team with son Alastair, 20, after heart surgery Katie Price squeezes into a barely-there purple bikini as she goes for a swim in Marbella after removing her wedding ring Chris Evans takes $1.6million haircut on Hollywood Hills mansion sale as Captain America star quits California for good Sasha Attwood and boyfriend Jack Grealish look loved-up as they enjoy romantic 'last minute' holiday together The one-hour tan from the A-list-loved brand everyone's raving about is a game-changer for busy days SHOPPING Celine Dion looks in great spirits as she waves to fans while leaving her hotel in Paris after making her first public appearance in two years  Billie Eilish mocked for hosting brother Finneas O'Connell's wedding on 'stolen land' after woke Grammys outburst Love Is Blind UK stars Catherine Richards and Jake Singleton-Hill welcome their first child together and reveal baby girl's adorable name Ariana Grande reveals she is suffering with a foot injury as she gives update on her final two London shows after concerned fans noticed her limping on stage Kim Kardashian donates $50K to families at the US-Mexico border at glitzy LA fundraiser Jennifer Garner shows off toned arms and age-defying figure in sporty ensemble while running errands in LA with teenage kid Fin Taylor Swift leaves mom-of-three emotional after 'surreal' $50K donation for medical bills Doja Cat hits back at 'demonic' claims and opens up about past drug addiction: 'I have struggled with cocaine' The best new films and TV series to watch on Netflix this month: From a 9/11 documentary to Ryan Murphy's latest Monster installment This retinol from Dr Sebagh has been specially formulated to provide all benefits of retinols - without any of the irritation SHOPPING Back to reality with a bang: Newlywed Love Island star Molly Smith picks up a parking ticket as she hits the gym after boozy 10-day Mallorca wedding to Tom Clare Sarah Jessica Parker reveals the biggest misconception fans have about her Harper Beckham's festival fashion parade: Teen teams denim hotpants and a crop top with a £2,500 necklace, £120 wellies and a £130 GAP jacket by mum Victoria as she watches Cruz perform at Reading MAFS star Jessika Power shares photos of her disturbing domestic violence injuries in confronting video after she revealed she was hospitalised following abuse Primark has parents rushing to snap up school uniform essentials from just a fiver SHOPPING Pregnant Laura Woods celebrates three year anniversary with fiancé Adam Collard as she shares cosy snaps ahead of the pair welcoming their second child together EXCLUSIVE'Everyone in Nashville is terrified to say it out loud': Grammy-winning snitch spares no one in savage name-and-shame ranking of singers vying for Dolly Parton's crown as the next Queen of Country: ROB SHUTER This explosive thriller moves so fast, there's no time to ponder the plot holes: CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews Trigger Point BBC airs footage of hip hop star Loyle Carner rapping 'f*** Nigel Farage' and 'free Palestine' during Reading Festival set Dolly Parton's estate brings country icon's 'dream' to life with international music festival to honor her legacy... after her death at 80 Jaime Pressly escorted away from swanky hotel bar after 'appearing under the influence'... just months after joining OnlyFans Tim McGraw and Faith Hill's daughter Maggie is ENGAGED to boyfriend James Rubin as she flashes massive ring... after dad's humiliating on-stage mishap Inside Millie Mackintosh's new home: Star opens her doors for a tour of her house as she embarks on life as a single mum after split from Hugo Taylor Rob and Michele Reiner's son Jake quietly marries girlfriend Maria Gilfillan... eight months after the murder of his parents Kelly Clarkson's talk show ends TODAY: Inside 'emotional' final episode with singer's two kids Newlywed Tallulah Willis, 32, swaps bridal glam for low-key comfort as she's pictured for the first time since tying the knot with Justin Acee in lavish ceremony EXCLUSIVELove Is Blind stars reveal what you didn't see in the pods - from secret dates to Emma Willis' sweet words of advice Sacha Baron Cohen's new Ali G movie is criticised for 'racist stereotypes' as backlash mounts and campaigners petition to get Who Iz I banned MAFS UK star Holly Ditchfield announces she has given birth to her twins four months early as she details 'scary and surreal' labour MAFS star Gemma Rose Barnes welcomes son Remy after seven miscarriages as she shares post-birth health struggles following caesarean Lila Moss looks just like model mum Kate as she sports a tiny bikini on the beach in Formentera Hilaria Baldwin, 42, shares her fitness routine and diet after flaunting her toned abs in bikini video EXCLUSIVEHayden Panettiere mother's stage mom confessions: Truth about 'pep pills' at age 15 'The year no-one saw': Unseen Love Is Blind couple Sammy and Jon reveal they are still together after Netflix axed them from final cut Models, fashion icons and stars gather for funerals of Dior executive Mathilde Favier and her film producer partner Nicolas Altmayer The Gentlemen star Kaya Scodelario goes public with new romance with director Eran Creevy - two years after divorce from father of her children Friendly exes Fergie and Josh Duhamel both share rare snaps of their 'cool' son Axl as they celebrate his 13th birthday: 'Holy crap that went fast' D4vd's attorneys QUIT as a public defender takes over in murder trial amid concerns over finances Christine McGuinness turns heads in a tiny khaki bikini and vows 'I don't give a f**k anymore' in defiant posts amid ex Paddy's new romance Mel C unveils tattoo tribute to her favourite Ibiza club as she is inked with the iconic 'Pacha cherries' before joining Roger Sanchez on the decks The One Show host Alex Jones cuddles shirtless husband Charlie Thomson as she opens up her holiday photo album from family sailing trip Mel Gibson slammed for mocking deaf ASL interpreter on stage at a fan expo: 'Despicable' Amanda Abbington gets to work on set with Emma Thompson in first major TV role since Strictly as Giovanni Pernice 'bullying' row erupts again Katie Price removes her wedding ring as she lets loose in a daring cut-out mini-dress on wild trip to Marbella Dolly Parton's niece honors her 'granny' for 'loving' her like her own child after superstar's funeral Former Coronation Street star Adam Rickitt, 48, proves he's still got soap heartthrob status as he shows off his muscular six-pack while performing at Pride EXCLUSIVELove Island's Shaughna Phillips details boyfriend Billy's sweet bond with their daughters after he missed their eldest's birth while in prison Kimberley Walsh shows off her toned figure in a blue bikini as she sips a frozen cocktail in carefree family snaps from holiday to Spain It's Construction Spice! Mel B operates a mechanical digger as renovation work continues on her £2.2 million dream country bolthole in Yorkshire  John Galliano withdraws from Met Gala 2027 amid backlash over antisemitic rant 'Happy days with my babies': Princess Eugenie posts new photos showing her new daughter Adelaide with her two sons August and Ernest Strictly's Karen Hauer, 44, flashes her abs in a skimpy bikini as she shares rare snaps with boyfriend Simon Davidson after being axed from show EXCLUSIVE'I used to be very busy... I'm worth it!': Love Is Blind star Ciara defends her wild dating demands after fans accused her of being 'spoilt' for having a £15K first date Poppy Jamie reveals she is seven months pregnant with her first child after a 'multi-year fertility journey' and two 'incomprehensible' late miscarriages Baywatch bombshell Carmen Electra, 54, shocks fans as she poses topless in very racy new photos Meghan tends to vegetable garden in new As Ever photo days after she and Harry returned to UK - as sources reveal how they spent last weekend in US Sarah Ferguson is 'lined up for a tell-all TV interview' as she returns to Britain 'in the next few days' after fallout over Epstein links 'Spitting some real pain': Stormzy's viral 2018 review of Dolly Parton's Jolene leaves fans in hysterics as it trends after the music icon's death Princess Diana's niece Lady Kitty Spencer, 35, shows off her svelte figure in a polka dot bikini as she holidays with rarely-seen billionaire husband Michael Lewis, 67 EXCLUSIVE'Frustrated' Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce are hardly seeing each other: 'She knew the honeymoon would be short. She knew what she signed up for' 'My heart is hurting': Ollie Watkins' wife Ellie breaks down in tears over sudden move to Saudi Arabia after footballer's transfer from Aston Villa to Al-Hilal Mel B's daughter Phoenix Chi, 27, bags her first acting role as she lands a part in dramatic Hollyoaks kidnapping plot Denise Welch, 68, struts her stuff in a plunging black swimsuit as she enjoys a sun-soaked holiday after quitting Loose Women EXCLUSIVEThe Dolly Parton songs no one has ever heard: Inside secret music vault she built for her death... as insiders reveal private plans singer 'laid out for her family' Entourage star Debi Mazar calls out the 'toxic testosterone-fuelled environment' on set as she claims she was body-shamed when she returned to work after having a baby Posh's bumper payday: Victoria Beckham 'ecstatic' as her £104 sold-out foundation helps boost her company profits to £7.3million Gwyneth Paltrow 'postpones' dinner at her Hamptons home held in honour of controversial billionaire OpenAI CEO Sam Altman after backlash Iconic TV series 7 Up is slapped with trigger warning by ITV bosses for 'containing outdated attitudes' Kerry Katona, 45, turns heads in an eye-popping metallic dress during night out with her boyfriend Paolo Margaglione, 33, and lookalike daughter Heidi, 19 Dolly Parton's sister Frieda shares emotional tribute to the country icon as she reflects on their 'highs and lows': 'I never stopped loving her' Louise Redknapp, 51, shares bikini snaps after 'splitting from boyfriend of two years Drew Michael, 42'  - a year after revealing their marriage plans . Cruz Beckham rocks Leeds Festival a day after Victoria and David supported him at Reading - as he pays tribute to girlfriend Jackie Apostel for her support of his music career Randy Quaid SLAMS Anne Hathaway's casting in Days of Thunder 2 as he calls her 'too woke' and a 'horrible choice' Selena Gomez kisses husband Benny Blanco as they enjoy a romantic water taxi ride in Venice Kylie Jenner names her favorite sister during chaotic Q&A with her kids Stormi, eight, and Aire, four... after shutting down pregnancy rumors John Travolta rocks ANOTHER beret at Ramones 50th anniversary tribute... after fans mercilessly roasted his 'kooky' style Justin Bieber cozies up to wife Hailey at Billie Eilish's brother Finneas' wedding to longtime partner Claudia Sulewski Paris Fury decorates for Halloween two months early as she shows off her pumpkin-themed kitchen Hugh Jackman offers fans free rent - as his $40million New York apartment he shared with ex-wife Deborra-Lee struggles to sell The celebs who behaved VERY badly this summer: Etiquette Queen LAURA WINDSOR names and shames this season's most uncivilised stars Sophie Habboo poses topless while cradling son Ziggy as she shares sweet snaps with husband Jamie Laing to mark the end of summer Brooks Nader leaves little to the imagination in sizzling white dress as she steps out for dinner in Saint-Tropez It's the Arctic's luminous beauty that makes this icy thriller so cool: CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews BBC's Vigil Met Gala could be rescheduled amid growing row with Jewish community over tribute to British designer John Galliano 15 years on from his antisemitic rant Furious Dolly Parton fans tear into Mississippi mayor after he opposes lowering flag for the late music icon: 'I'd lower it for Dolly before any politician!' Days of Thunder star Randy Quaid goes on bizarre tirade against Tom Cruise for not having his ex-wife Nicole Kidman in remake Sydney Sweeney strips down to lacy lingerie for steamy SYRN shoot ahead of her 29th birthday EXCLUSIVEGary Lineker and Graeme Souness forced to put their differences aside for new ITV gameshow The Box as ex-Liverpool midfielder said he wanted to 'smash' his nemesis a few times' during filming Susanna Reid reveals she broke her teetotal rule and was enjoying tequila cocktails with her sons when she posted Ibiza swimsuit snaps EXCLUSIVE'They are smashing it. It's the ultimate sod you to the BBC': Inside John Torode's VERY lucrative new life with wife Lisa Faulkner EXCLUSIVERanvir Singh reveals she overcame her phobia of water for new ITV gameshow The Box and says it helped her bond with her teenage son Dolly Parton is on course for her first ever UK number one as her hit 1980 song 9 To 5 soars into the charts days after icon died Hairy Biker Dave Myers' wife sells his personal belongings at auction two years on from his death as she says the sale is 'healing' her grief Billie Eilish's brother Finneas marries longtime girlfriend Claudia Sulewski... and the pop star officiates the ceremony Brittany Cartwright speaks out after getting restraining order against ex Jax Taylor It's Beatlemania! BBC's Beatles drama Hamburg Days starts shooting in Liverpool city centre... as rival film biopic takes over London Iris Law shows off her toned figure in a skimpy green bikini as she gives a glimpse of her fun-filled summer EXCLUSIVEBroadchurch's Daphne Neville is selling her 'magical Cotswold mill house' for £1.8million - as she leaves the house she's called home for the last 60 years Gareth Gates sheds his squeaky clean Pop Idol persona as he strips off during racy Manchester Pride performance Dolly Parton is honored by Grand Ole Opry following her shock death at age 80 after secret cancer battle INSIDE STORY'My cousin and I were both Dolly Parton fans - the type who'd belt out 9 to 5 on the dance floor at Coppers - but that all changed when we visited the poverty-ridden Appalachian region she came from... Duran Duran frontman Simon Le Bon, 67, clutches a beer on inflatable boat ride during family holiday with wife Yasmin on luxury yacht in Sardinia EXCLUSIVEHorror icon, 78, who starred in '70s slasher film and co-wrote action flick starring Kurt Russell seen on rare outing... can you guess who he is? Dame Meera Syal reveals she was sexually assaulted by an older actor who offered to help boost her career  Sorry Brooklyn, the Beckhams have a new favourite photographer: Victoria's niece Libby Adams snaps away during cousin Cruz's Reading Festival set Cruz Beckham dedicates a song to 'my little sister' before Harper takes to the stage to the delight of fans at Reading Festival As Harry and Meghan's 'rock' Doria turns 70, how the Duchess's supportive mother will now have to live an ocean away from her grandchildren and the couple she stood by following 'Megxit' fallout Katie Price shows off her 'owned by Lee' tattoo and the full extent of her surgically-enhanced body by the pool in Ibiza - as husband remains in jail Strictly's head judge Shirley Ballas at the centre of 'fix' row as her close relationship with celebrity contestant Dani Dyer is revealed Scott Wolf responds after estranged wife Kelley apologizes for 'nightmare' drama after mental health diagnosis Amanda Abbington's C-word rant at Giovanni Pernice: As she hits back after dancer shared his side of the story, friends reveal her 'outrageous behaviour' to KATIE HIND 'He abused his power... it was dealt with': Ray Winstone claims he 'slapped and threatened' a director who 'groped' his female co-star on set as movie hardman laments the 'different world today' How 'quiet' Lady Louise is using the late Queen and Prince Philip as a blueprint for her blossoming relationship with university boyfriend Felix da Silva-Clamp: ROBERT JOBSON EXCLUSIVEI told the BBC about an abusive colleague - but still had to work with them, says former Strictly professional Nadiya Bychkova Phil Foden's seven-year-old son is looking to hire a £50,000-a-year social media manager...after he hit nearly 4 million followers on Instagram 'He expects an apology. He's not changed': Friends reveal Harry is 'still angry' with members of the Royal Family and why his return to Britain is not a change of heart Olivia Attwood shares smitten snap of boyfriend Pete Wicks in an 'I love my girlfriend' T-shirt after 'hard launching' their relationship EXCLUSIVEI can be an amazing mum... and still do OnlyFans: Ex-Hollyoaks star Sarah Jayne Dunn snaps at trolls and says 'I want my son to see me be an independent woman' Late Glee star Naya Rivera's son, 10, steps into acting six years after her tragic drowning death Howard Stern's next career move is revealed after his channel 101 was DROPPED by SiriusXM... following mass layoffs 'They only made friends with people who could help them': What Meghan and Harry's Montecito neighbours REALLY think of them Keeping up with Maya? How Jama is planning to become the British Kim Kardashian after stealing the reality star's style, building a list of famous exes and launching her own business Harry Styles dashes to his New York show in his signature shorts before cracking cheeky joke about his ex Taylor Swift's Madison Square Garden wedding during gig Tom Cruise makes heartbreaking Kyle Busch gesture at NASCAR race after new 'Days of Thunder' movie is confirmed Brooklyn Beckham enjoys cosy night in with wife Nicola Peltz at their LA bolthole as his estranged family unite to celebrate Cruz's Reading Festival debut How Emma Willis stays SO youthful: Strictly Come Dancing host, 50, looks better than she did in her 20s thanks to these fitness routines and skincare tricks How celebrities have spent their summer holidays: From Jamie Oliver's 'secret' UK island trip to Stacey Solomon's three luxurious holidays Bebe Rexha brutally shuts down romance rumors with Knicks NBA champion after flirty date nights Kylie Minogue, 58, shows off her youthful looks in Vogue Australia - and reveals her drunken girls' night out with fellow Aussie Margot Robbie Dolly Parton's devastated loved ones gather at Nashville burial site where Queen of Country is laid to rest in heels beside husband Carl Dean EXCLUSIVEDazzling WAGs, Hollywood stars and bizarre shaman rituals: Top-ranked female poker player reveals the glitz and glamour of the wealthy underground scene Married at First Sight Australia expert warns 2027 season will be rife with 'extreme views' and 'influenced by TikTok' - after groom 'suddenly exits' show EXCLUSIVE'Controlling' Sandra Bullock cut off her late partner Bryan from loved ones: That's the bombshell claim by insiders... but she tells a very different story Taylor Swift's famous ex Harry Styles breaks silence on her wedding to Travis Kelce Ariana Grande's Wicked co-star Jonathan Bailey proves there's no hard feelings as he cheers her on at O2 gig weeks after popstar suddenly pulled out of their London play EXCLUSIVE'I finally feel sexy for the first time: Hollyoaks' James Sutton, 43,  reveals he's 'shutting the door' on acting after 'emotionally checking out' to focus on new OnlyFans career Proud parents David and Victoria Beckham cheer on son Cruz and his band The Breakers as they make their Reading debut as the whole family watch from backstage Vigil vs Trigger Point: As BBC and ITV's hit dramas go head-to-head which show should YOU tune in for tonight? 'I blamed myself': GK Barry bravely reveals for the first time she was raped when she was 17 by an older male boss while doing work experience As Casualty bosses admit the show was an attack on Thatcher, can you recognise these superstars whose careers were launched on the show?