# Stop calling Keir Starmer a good man **By:** Oli Dugmore **Published:** 2026-07-22T15:08:10+01:00 **Source:** [New Statesman](https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/uk-politics/2026/07/stop-calling-keir-starmer-a-good-man) --- It is not decent to lie, or to indulge warmongers ![](https://dl6pgk4f88hky.cloudfront.net/2026/07/21/3f17ahy-797x1062.jpg) Photo by NL Beeld/Alamy Live News Mercifully, Keir Starmer is no longer prime minister. Though my unadulterated jubilation has been moderated by the shame of Atlanta, I’m glad – glad to see the back of the man it would be harsh to describe as Labour’s worst prime minister, but can fairly be called its most pathetic. Copiously present in national life, but utterly irrelevant to our meaningful existence, like nitrogen. The ambient man. Starmer’s great skill was a lawyerly awareness of what to say and when, how to avoid verbal ensnarement and diplomatic complication, and – crucially, when it came to facing Boris Johnson – the application of those same mechanisms to his enemies while in opposition. So what intrigued me about Starmer was that, despite this clear grasp of the power of language, he said so little, and meant less of it still. Do you seriously believe that Burnham does not ever lie or indulge warmongers? If so, why did he call Donald Trump as one of his first acts? Why did he mislead us about the funding of the VAT cut for electricity? On the other hand, If not, what is the point of this childish article? I do agree with main thrust of this piece. Starme r did lie.Sometimes in the most transparent way He appeared on camera saying that Corbyn was his “friend” only to deny he’d ever said it,again on camera, later,. His treatment of Corbyn was positively shameful, as was his continuing support of the Israeli genocide More a duplicitous man than a good one! Here Here!!! Re comments validation: Please correct your grammar – it is EITHER Awaiting validation OR Waiting for validation NOT Awaiting for validation. TutTut. I thought the Grauniad had got past that! A bit of a rubbish article not becoming of the NS. Some of the points raised are correct – the LBC interview was shocking – and more should have been made of this – but a rant does Oli no favours. He argues about the Lords still being there, but if Starmer was given only two years (not five) he cannot argue this promise was not delivered (of course, like every leader before him, they have all failed to deliver on this promise). Oli likes his pet subjects, of course. But to suggest a social media ban (the subject being looked at by governments across the world – I remain agnostic on this – waiting to see more evidence and argument before jumping), and the imprisoning of Lucy Connelly was not right, is simply bonkers. Oli clearly carries a flame for Faiza Shaheen, as though no Labour leader (including JC) has done such a thing before. And where is the most obvious target – the Winter Fuel Allowance debacle? No Labour leader/Party should ever have suggested the change proposed – and that has not been forgotten – except by Oli it seems. Like so many articles recently, I expect NS to do far better than this. I agree. This article is typical of the black and white thinking that seems to pass for intellect these days. Let’s cancel Keir Starmer! If he’s not 100 per cent he is obviously 100 per cent bad. To get elected every Labour leader has told the party faithfull one thing and the electorate another. The two election processes are totally different. Most political parties do the same but for Labour we seem to want to hold ourselves to a different standard. It’s rubbish! Most Labour MPs seem to end up in parliament after being a reseacher for an MP and prior to that working for a charity straight out of university. It’s a tough career and they do not call it the greasy pole for nothing e.g. the last couple of months. Andy Burnham tells Labour voters what they want to hear for now because the messages blend well with dealing with the steep rises in the cost of living (more rises to come). Let’s see what messages the Labour government are putting out this time next year. I think Oli has long ago decided that he hates Keir and here’s a good opportunity to give him a good kicking. In reality many of Keir’s failings occured because he and Rachel Reeves are managerial and insufficiently instinctive. A friend of mine (also an MP) would say cock up rather than conspiracy. I agree that Jeremy Corbyn was treated badly by many (not only by Keir) but Oli is frankly just as bad in putting the boot in. I am a long time supporter of Andy Burnham and Steve Rotherham who have led the way in applying traditional Labour movement traditions to the problems we face. I love the idea of a mass council house building policy, whats not to like? I am looking forward to Conference in Liverpool and engaging in the fringe debates as we enter a more Atlee/Wilson era of Labour Government. I think Andy should brand us, not New Labour but Real Labour. Brilliant article. The answer, is no. Burnham cannot do any better. His record in Manchester is mixed. He too, is ankle flashing Labour’s base who have long deserted them. While offering nothing on climate other than the status quo and nothing on foreign policy. Trying to ignore the last two will work for a while, but the rubber will meet the road, probably within the next 6 months. The political cycle moves far faster than the establishment can appsreciate. I enjoyed this, especially amongst all the eulogies and guff. Starmer was a liar who lied in order to get into power – but didn’t have a clue what to do once he was there. He fell into the usual trap of thinking he was in power when he was merely in office. His proudest claim was to “save the Labour Party” – presumable from Corbyn and the Left. He is no better than May or Cameron in confusing the interests of his party with the interests of the country.